New Appraisal Rules Bad for Consumers and Recovery

By Brian Short, CMC, CRMS, GMA

Beginning on May 1st of this year (2009) any home buyer or homeowner getting a new mortgage on their house will be up-charged $150-$250 for their appraisal and generally charged an additional $968 to close their new loan!  You mean, you never heard about this?  You thought the government was doing all it could to stimulate the struggling housing industry?  Guess again!

A year ago, one attorney general in New York, with a famous last name,

NY AG Andrew Cuomo

NY AG Andrew Cuomo

Cuomo,  struck a deal with Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac to keep them out of a potentially very ugly and very public law suit because of blind eyes they had been turning to a now bankrupt bank, Washington Mutual. 

You see, WaMu (as they are known in the banking world) had a side business they were operating where they started an Appraisal Management Firm where they required their loans to include an appraisal only from those “independent” appraisers who would join their firm and work for 3/4 of what most professional-level appraisers would work. 

Keep in mind, this did not lower the cost to the consumer.  Their appraisals still cost the same.  It was simply another income stream for the bank and a way to control who did their appraisals.  These appraisers soon learned who “buttered their bread” and were very careful to give the federally chartered bank the value they needed to get their loan closed.  Sounds fishy, huh?  YOU BET IT DOES!

Now enters the young Cuomo, called Andrew, with his eyes on bigger political prizes.  He uncovers this corruption and sues WaMu, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac – who all seemed to know that WaMu was doing this.  (Countrywide/Bank of America STILL own their Appraisal Management firm – Landsafe!)  To head off this embarrassing high-profile lawsuit they struck an “out-of-court” settlement which goes far beyond the jurisdiction of the state attorney general.

He asked for, and received, assurances that no Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac loans would ever be accepted by federally chartered banks who required that their appraisals were done by their own appraisal management firms?  Right?  Wrong!!  Wrong!!  Wrong!!

This new agreement which went into effect on May 1st exempted ALL FEDERALLY CHARTERED BANKS!  The new agreement, crafted in Albany, NY was never approved by Congress or any state legislature. It was drawn up in some back-room to avoid a trial against a corrupt bank doing corrupt business with a corrupt Appraisal Management firm they owned – most likely known about by both corrupt Government Sponsored Entities (GSE’s) Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae!  And to top it off, ALL FEDERALLY CHARTERED BANKS are exempt!  This new “back-room agreement” only affects mortgage brokers and bankers who are generally supervised or chartered by state banking regulators.

WaMu is NoMoIf that was not enough, it now requires all appraisals to be ordered through APPRAISAL MANAGEMENT FIRMS!!!  This very same corrupt system that WaMu used to artificially inflate their appraisal values to ensure that their loans would close – making sure that no independent third parties were involved in the process of assigning values to the properties under consideration!  What?!?!? 

I thought it was the corrupt Appraisal Management Firm model of business that had proven itself to be untrustworthy in the New York back-room in that courthouse in Albany?  Why is it that Mr. Cuomo would wrongly insist that ALL APPRAISALS now be ordered and up-charged by centralized corporate middle-men who do not know local property values, local building standards, and local business practices.  This new layer of New York mandated bureaucracy is required all across the country without a single vote or hearing from industry insiders on how it would negatively affect the struggling mortgage and Real Estate industries. 

These “middle-men” are unregulated by any federal or state agency but have been given the task of arranging for 70-80% of all mortgages being closed in the country and up-charging the cost of that appraisal by $150-$250 per order and passing that cost on to the unassuming buyer or homeowner.  Those $300 appraisals are now costing $400 – $500 for someone outside the state to assign the work to someone with whom they have a working agreement who may or may not live in the area, ever work in the area, or have ever researched the housing market in the area of where the appraisal needs to be done. 

What is their qualification for getting to do this appraisal for this Appraisal Management Firm?  They have promised to work cheap and fast!  Is that who you want to do your appraisal?  Cheap and fast?!?  Who benefits from this arrangement?  The host of newly formed unregulated and unsupervised Appraisal Management Firms are making out like bandits!  Everyone else in the transaction is supervised by a state or federal agency or governing board – Realtors, Mortgage Professionals, Home Inspectors, Insurance Agents, Surveyors, Builders, Title Agents, Appraisers – they’re all tested, licensed, and regulated.  Who tests, licenses or regulates the Appraisal Management Firms?  Why should they be making any money in this transaction?  What are they professionals at doing?  Looking at the next name on a list of random appraisers who have agreed to work for what they will pay them – even if they are not local professionals themselves.

It is reported that this new layer of middle-men have added another 5-10 days on the already very slow loan underwriting timetable causing delays in loan closings which cost the borrower an additional $500-$1,000 to extend the rate lock so they still receive the rate they agreed to receive at the time of the loan application.  Some have estimated that this new over-reaching agreement will cost Americans $2.8 BILLION EVERY YEAR and cause weeks of delays in closing Real Estate mortgages!

Let me make sure I get this right – the consumer is paying anywhere from $650- $1,250 to get an inferior appraisal done which takes longer to get back simply because a nationally chartered bank had an Appraisal Management Firm in their “back pocket” and they were so corrupt that they are no longer in business.  That was the punishment put on all American borrowers by one attorney general in one state up in the northeast because he had dirt on some crooks at Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac?  This can’t be good! 

Would you like to join the thousands of housing industry professionals in calling those who forced this on you and your neighbors without a single vote or hearing?  CLICK HERE to see who you can call and make your voice of protest heard.

Advertisements

3 Responses to New Appraisal Rules Bad for Consumers and Recovery

  1. This was a very informative post, I’ve added your blog to my google reader. Thank you!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

w

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: